Wolvie...It has worked for me using Cabots penetrating oils. Maybe, because everyone in this are buys the cheap composites at our local menard's home improvement warehouse. I believe it has less glue solids and the Cabot's seems to grab to the particles. I'm not sure. I know with my testing of the p oils it seems cabot has a higher dye content than the others. It seems that they use more pigment than dye. It works on uprights pretty well I drive past two jobs I've done every other day and they look great after a year and half.