Sorry to bump an old thread.
First time staining a Plastpro Fir Grain Craftsman style door. I used Zar oil-based "Provincial" stain and applied it with a foam brush and worked it in with a circular motion with a stain cloth. I then brushed it with a foam brush.
If I try to wipe it off with a stain cloth, the stain comes off the raised texture portion mostly while settling in the grooves. So instead of doing this, I didn't wipe off but tried to feather off excess stain with a dry bristle brush.
In the end it looks like it went on too thick now. 48 hours since I stained and it's still a bit tacky and has a high sheen.
Should I have stuck with the wiping off method?
https://goo.gl/photos/2T9zgLnmw3CQR1pA8
Thanks